How the right discount follow-up increased BK Beauty’s placed order rate by 36%

BK Beauty, a cosmetics brand founded by former MAC trainer and YouTube creator Lisa J, is known for its luxurious, vegan, and cruelty-free beauty tools and makeup. When the brand’s welcome flow underperformed, our team at Fuel Made stepped in to refine their email strategy and drive more conversions from first-time subscribers.

  • 118% placed order rate increase in the first welcome email
  • 15% open rate increase
  • 13% conversion rate increase for the entire welcome flow
BK Beauty True Beauty eyeshadow palettes on a burgundy background
Client BK Beauty
Industry Cosmetics
Website bkbeauty.com

Fuel Made's Role

  • Strategy
  • Copywriting
  • Visual Design
  • List Growth
  • Full Service Email Marketing
Original welcome email offering 10% off sitewide with a code, featuring three smiling women Before
Original welcome email inviting subscribers to follow the brand for makeup tips Before

The challenge

Underperforming welcome flow

BK Beauty’s original welcome flow wasn’t converting well. The emails following their pop-up sign-up were cluttered and busy, distracting users from making a purchase.

Limited subscriber data

The pop-up only collected email addresses, restricting communication to one channel instead of expanding to SMS. This meant missed opportunities to engage subscribers more effectively and boost ROI.

Redesigned email and SMS sign-up pop-ups by Fuel Made offering 10% and 15% off a first purchase After
Redesigned welcome email by Fuel Made offering 10% off a first order with makeup brush photography After
We’re SUPER HAPPY with everything that was delivered! Our new automated flows have dramatically improved retention and boosted BK Beauty’s monthly sales, while giving us confidence that our investment with Fuel Made will continue to compound in value as we accelerate brand growth.
Paul Jauregui Co-founder, BK Beauty

Our approach

Two-step pop-up for email and SMS

We redesigned BK Beauty’s pop-up to collect both email and SMS. Subscribers were segmented by communication type. Improved discount incentives drove more valuable sign-ups and increased overall engagement.

Simplified, high-converting discount follow-up

We replaced the cluttered design with a clean, premium look that put the discount front and center. Adding urgency through an expiration date and easy-to-navigate product links made the offer irresistible.

A focused welcome email

Thirty minutes after the discount email, a personalized welcome message from founder Lisa J was sent to create an immediate emotional connection. The revised layout eliminated distracting links, focusing instead on driving users directly to shop.

Results

  • 118% Placed order rate increase in the first welcome email
  • 15% Open rate increase
  • 13% Conversion rate increase for the entire welcome flow
Founder story email by Fuel Made about the brand's mission, with a video thumbnail After
American Tall feature image: a tall man in a plaid shirt and cap leaning against a dark wall

Next Case Study

American Tall

How American Tall sent personalized emails and doubled welcome flow conversion rate from 5.45% to 11.06%

Read Next Case Study

Ready to work with us?